On the Browns' next possession, Mayfield connected with Landry on a spectacular 29-yard pass just outside the end zone to set up a 1-yard Carlos Hyde touchdown dive.
Much has been made of the Victory Fridges that Bud Light installed throughout Cleveland, giving fans free booze if the clock hit zero and the Browns found themselves on top. He has thrown five interceptions through three games.
Isaiah Crowell had two touchdown runs for the Jets (1-2), who seemed in control when they took a 14-0 lead and knocked Taylor from the game.
The drive culminated in a field goal to get the Browns on the board, cutting the lead to 14-3. Mayfield caught a pass from Landry on a variant of the Eagles' famous "Philly Special" for a two-point conversion to tie it at 14.
Newly signed Browns kicker Greg Joseph made field goals of 45 and 27 yards after being signed just three days ago.
At the start of the play, Mayfield ran out of the backfield on a pass pattern and the ball was directly snapped to running back Duke Johnson Jr.